Former Letcher County Sheriff Shawn “Mickey” Stines has officially pleaded not guilty to the murder of District Court Judge Kevin Mullins. This incident took place in the very courthouse where Stines reportedly opened fire on Judge Mullins back in September.
Stines’ attorney, Jeremy Bartley, stated that they have a strong defense prepared, focusing on the circumstances surrounding the shooting. He mentioned that the timing of Stines’ deposition in a related sexual abuse lawsuit just days earlier could play a critical role in the case.
After Monday’s short court session, Bartley remarked, “It’s a large story… and we look forward to sharing a more complete version as we go through this judicial process.”
The lawsuit involves serious allegations against a former deputy of Stines, who is accused of coercing a woman into performing sexual favors in the same judge’s office where the shooting occurred. This has raised questions about Stines’ conduct and his responsibilities as sheriff.
Prosecutor Jackie Steele declined to comment on whether the deposition played a role in the shooting but indicated that he does not anticipate any additional charges for Stines other than the murder charge. The possibility of pursuing the death penalty is still under consideration.
Stines was denied bail during the hearing. The judge, Julia H. Adams, took considerable time to make this decision, citing the nature of the charges against Stines as a significant factor.
Having resigned from his position at the end of September, Stines is currently being held in a different county’s jail. Despite the shocking nature of the case, details regarding Stines’ motivations remain unclear.
The incident has left the local community in disbelief, with many expressing their shock and sadness about the events that unfolded, particularly regarding the tragic loss of Judge Mullins, who was known in the community as a fair and respected figure. The future of this case may reveal deeper insights into the pressures faced by law enforcement officials and the tragic outcomes they can sometimes lead to.
