A Promising Athlete Faces Unexpected Roadblock
A gifted high school athlete from Long Island, celebrated for his role in leading his school to a state soccer championship the previous year, has encountered an unexpected hurdle. Ryan Leary, a senior at Carle Place High School, was initially given the go-ahead to participate in both soccer and football this fall. However, district officials intervened, preventing him from pursuing both sports simultaneously.
Leary had discussed the possibility of balancing both varsity sports with Carle Place football coach Paul Selhorn before the start of the school year. He was assured that his participation would be welcomed. Leary also spoke with athletic director Justin Block, who told him the decision was up to him.
Leary began splitting his time between the two sports, committed to defending Carle Place’s Class B Boys Soccer State Championship while also contributing to the football team as a wide receiver and kicker.
However, school officials had other ideas.
Superintendent Ted Cannone informed Leary that he would not be allowed to play for both teams. Faced with an ultimatum, Leary reluctantly chose to focus on football, hoping to later find a way to also play soccer.
Understandably, Leary was disappointed by the decision. He was told he could only be a “full-fledged” member of one team, or he could join the soccer team and be only the football kicker.
Cannone stated the school district’s rule was made for the safety of students and to keep things fair for all team members. He claimed that playing two high-contact sports in the same season was not a good idea.
NYS Section 8, which governs Nassau County public school athletics, has a different view. They allow student-athletes to compete in two sports during the same season, as long as they meet certain practice requirements and designate a primary sport in case of scheduling conflicts.
According to Section 8 executive director Patrick Pizzarelli, it is rare for a school to deny a student the chance to play two sports in the same season.
Leary, is now dedicating his athletic abilities to football for his senior year. He has already scored three touchdowns. Meanwhile, the Carle Place soccer team is struggling, with the soccer team not performing as well as expected.
The situation raises questions about the role of schools in guiding student-athletes. While safety is a priority, some argue that limiting opportunities for multi-talented students could hinder their development and potential. The debate continues about finding the right balance between safety, fairness, and allowing students to pursue their athletic passions.
