Court Upholds Injunction Against Florida’s Drag-Show Law
ATLANTA — A federal appeals court has decided to keep an injunction that prevents Florida from enforcing its law aimed at drag shows. The court ruled that the law likely violates the Constitution.
A panel from the 11th Circuit Court of Appeals voted 2-1 in favor of a lower court decision that criticized the law for being too broad and unclear. The case will now head back to the Middle District of Florida, where a trial may be scheduled.
Attorney Melissa Stewart, representing Hamburger Mary’s—a dining spot known for its drag shows—expressed relief that Florida’s First Amendment rights are being upheld as the legal battle continues. She stated, “The court’s opinion recognizes this law for what it is—a significant overreach intended to silence citizens’ speech and expression.”
Brian Wright, a spokesperson for Florida’s governor, criticized the ruling. He stated, “No one has a constitutional right to perform sexual routines in front of little kids. We will work diligently to overturn this lawless decision.”
Hamburger Mary’s in Orlando, which initiated this lawsuit in 2023, has regularly hosted drag shows, including family-oriented performances. Although the restaurant closed its downtown location last year, plans are in place for a new opening in Kissimmee. The owner argues that the Florida law suppresses free expression.
This legislation, backed by Republican Governor Ron DeSantis, aims to penalize venues that allow children to attend what it terms “adult live performances.” While the law does not explicitly mention drag shows, its sponsors have indicated that’s the target.
Under this law, venues could face hefty fines and potential suspension of liquor licenses. Individuals could also be charged with a misdemeanor for violations.
As this case unfolds, the balance between free speech and protecting children remains a contentious issue, highlighting differing values in today’s society.
